A vertical marketing system (VMS) is an integrated approach to the production, distribution, and marketing of products or services. In this system, the different levels of a distribution channel—such as producers, wholesalers, and retailers—work together in a coordinated and structured manner to achieve greater efficiency and market impact. As businesses strive to enhance their market reach and efficiency in 2024, understanding the types of vertical marketing systems has become crucial. This guide will walk you through what are the three major types of vertical marketing systems and help you understand the advantages and potential drawbacks of adopting a vertical marketing strategy.
What Is a Vertical Marketing System?
Table of Contents
In a vertical marketing system, the various members of a distribution channel collaborate closely, aiming to improve the flow of goods from the producer to the end consumer. Unlike traditional marketing, where each entity in the supply chain operates independently, a vertical marketing system aligns these members under a common goal to ensure smoother operation and better customer satisfaction.
The three major types of vertical marketing systems—corporate, contractual, and administered—each have their unique features and benefits. These types of vertical marketing are crucial for companies that seek to maximize coordination across their supply chain and enhance their marketing strategy.
How a Vertical Marketing System Works
A vertical marketing system works by creating a close-knit partnership among the members of the distribution channel. By collaborating effectively, businesses can achieve higher levels of efficiency and reduce redundancy in their production and distribution processes. The production and distribution of goods become streamlined, and the overall marketing efforts are better aligned with the company’s objectives or content.
This system requires coordination and collaboration across different types of businesses, from manufacturers and wholesalers to retailers and distributors. By working together, these entities can optimize the flow of products and services through the distribution chain.
Types of Vertical Marketing Systems
There are three major types of vertical marketing systems: corporate, contractual, and administered. Each of these types of vertical marketing systems offers unique advantages, depending on the size and goals of the businesses involved.
Corporate Vertical Marketing System
A corporate vertical marketing system is one in which a single company owns and controls all stages of the production and distribution chain. By owning the entire supply chain, the company can exercise complete control over the coordination of activities, from manufacturing to retailing. This allows the company to achieve economies of scale and ensure that the distribution process is tightly aligned with its overall marketing strategy.
For example, Zara, the global fashion retailer, is known for its corporate vertical marketing system, as it owns and controls much of its production and distribution processes. This control allows Zara to quickly respond to market demands and bring new products to the shelves faster than many of its competitors.
The main advantage of a corporate vertical marketing system is the control it provides over the entire supply chain. This control can lead to improved efficiency, cost savings, and the ability to meet customer needs more effectively. However, one potential drawback is the significant investment required to own and manage the entire supply chain.
Contractual Vertical Marketing System
A contractual vertical marketing system is based on formal agreements between the various members of the distribution channel. In this system, independent firms at different levels of production and distribution work together through contracts to achieve better coordination and efficiency. A franchise is a common example of a contractual vertical marketing system.
In a franchise system, the franchisor provides the brand, marketing support, and operational guidelines, while the franchisee operates the business under the franchise’s established system. Popular franchises like McDonald’s or Subway are excellent examples of how a contractual VMS works.
The advantages of a contractual vertical marketing system include the ability to leverage established brand recognition and marketing support while maintaining some level of operational independence. For franchisees, this provides a lower-risk entry into business ownership. However, a potential drawback could be the lack of flexibility, as franchisees are required to adhere to the franchisor’s guidelines and standards.
Administered Vertical Marketing System
In an administered vertical marketing system, one member of the distribution channel, typically a large company, exerts significant influence and control over the other members, even though they remain independent businesses. This control is often based on the size and power of one company within the channel, which can influence the activities of the other members without formal contracts.
Companies like Procter & Gamble and Walmart are prime examples of how an administered vertical marketing system works. Due to their market power, they can dictate terms to suppliers and retailers, ensuring that their products receive priority in the marketplace.
The advantage of an administered vertical marketing system is the ability to achieve significant market influence without the need for formal agreements or ownership of the entire supply chain. However, this system can also lead to potential conflicts, as smaller members of the distribution channel may feel pressured by the larger, more powerful companies.
Advantages of a Vertical Marketing System
Using a vertical marketing system can offer numerous benefits to businesses. The primary advantages include improved efficiency, better coordination, and increased market reach. By aligning the goals and activities of all members of the distribution channel, companies can reduce redundancy, lower costs, and ensure a more consistent customer experience.
Another benefit of using a vertical marketing system is that it allows companies to respond more quickly to changes in the market. Whether it’s launching new products and services or adapting to shifts in customer demand, a vertical marketing strategy enables faster decision-making and implementation across the entire supply chain.
Additionally, a vertical marketing system can enhance brand consistency. By controlling or influencing all aspects of the production and distribution process, companies can ensure that their brand messaging and product quality are consistent at every stage of the customer journey.
Potential Drawbacks of a Vertical Marketing System
So, what are the three major types of vertical marketing systems? While there are many advantages of a vertical marketing system, it’s important to be aware of the potential drawbacks as well. One potential issue is the loss of flexibility. In a corporate vertical marketing system, for example, owning and managing the entire supply chain can limit a company’s ability to adapt to changing market conditions or new opportunities.
Similarly, in a contractual vertical marketing system, the formal agreements between channel members can restrict the ability to innovate or pivot quickly. Franchisees, for example, may be limited in their ability to introduce new products or services that deviate from the franchisor’s established system.
Another potential drawback is the risk of conflict between channel members. In an administered vertical marketing system, for example, smaller companies may feel that their interests are not being adequately represented by the larger, more powerful member of the distribution channel. This can lead to tensions and inefficiencies in the distribution process.
Comment by Dr. Adrian Rivers, PhD, Marketing Strategy Expert
So, what are the three major types of vertical marketing systems? “In today’s complex marketplace, understanding the dynamics of marketing channels is essential for business owners who want to effectively sell their products. When we look at the three main types of marketing systems—corporate VMS, contractual, and administered—each offers distinct advantages depending on the company’s business objectives and the demographic they are targeting.
While horizontal marketing systems focus on businesses at the same level working together, understanding when to choose horizontal or vertical marketing is crucial. The logistics of a distribution channel can be daunting, but it’s helpful to learn how to use vertical marketing systems to streamline operations and meet customers’ needs more efficiently. For instance, large corporations like Zara, which owns its entire supply chain, demonstrate how vertical integration can reduce costs and logistics challenges while improving speed to market.
When considering the 3 types of vertical marketing systems, each structure enables companies to better wield their power across the distribution channel working together. The distribution system chosen impacts everything from how consumer goods are moved through the chain to how they are presented to potential customers. For companies, whether to opt for vertical or horizontal integration depends on factors like size, market presence, and how they plan to work together to improve efficiencies.
Platforms like Quizlet and Chegg.com can be invaluable resources for students and professionals alike when exploring marketing concepts. Whether you’re creating a vertical marketing strategy or comparing it to horizontal options, it’s crucial to understand the benefits and limitations. For example, in a corporate VMS, where Zara owns much of the supply chain, control over the intermediary steps of production and distribution can streamline processes and reduce reliance on third parties.
For any company, understanding how companies use different systems to distribute their products can be the central message in your strategic planning. The question you’re looking to answer is simple: how do these systems align with your goals? The answer to solved challenges lies in selecting the structure that best fits your needs and ensures all parties involved are working toward the same goal, three types and benefits of a vertical marketing”
Conclusion for Benefits of Using a Vertical Marketing System
So, what are the three major types of vertical marketing systems? The vertical marketing system offers a powerful way for companies to optimize their production and distribution processes while enhancing their overall marketing strategy. By understanding the three major types of vertical marketing systems—corporate, contractual, and administered—businesses can choose the approach that best aligns with their goals and resources. Whether you’re looking to increase efficiency, improve brand consistency, or expand your market reach, adopting a vertical marketing system can provide significant benefits.
However, it’s essential to carefully consider the potential drawbacks, such as reduced flexibility and the risk of conflict between channel members. By weighing these factors, companies can make informed decisions about how to structure their supply chains and maximize the impact of their marketing efforts in 2024 and beyond.